When it comes to sun protection, we're spoiled for choice. Creams, lotions, sticks... each format offers its own unique advantages. Today, we're putting two natural SPF options to the test, focusing on their format and overall user experience.
- Sky&Sol SPF 50: This is your classic cream sunscreen, known for its tallow-rich formula and natural ingredients.
- Badger Balm Sunscreen Face Stick SPF 35: This is all about convenience, offering sun protection in a portable, easy-to-apply stick.
Which format is right for you? Which sunscreen delivers the best protection and feel? Let's dive in and compare these two popular options
User Experience: Creamy vs. Convenient Application
The way a sunscreen feels and how easily it applies can significantly impact how often we use it. Let's compare the user experience of Sky&Sol's cream format with Badger's convenient stick.
Sky&Sol SPF 50
Sky&Sol offers a traditional cream sunscreen experience, but how does it feel and apply?
Texture and Application
- Rich and creamy, with a balm-like consistency.
- Requires thorough massaging to blend evenly.
- Provides a dewy finish, which might not be ideal for everyone.
- Can leave a white cast if not applied carefully.
User Experience
- Feels nourishing and moisturizing, especially for dry skin.
- Application can be time-consuming, not ideal for quick application.
Badger Balm Sunscreen Face Stick SPF 35
Badger offers a convenient stick format, designed for ease of use and portability.
Texture and Application
- A solid balm that glides onto the skin.
- Provides targeted application, making it easy to apply to specific areas.
- Can feel slightly waxy or heavy.
User Experience
- Very convenient for on-the-go application and reapplication.
- Might not provide as even coverage as a cream.
- Can also leave a white cast if not applied correctly.
Real-World Testing
Let's see how these formats perform in real-world scenarios.
Ease of Application:
Ease of Application
- Sky&Sol: While requiring more time, the cream format ensures a thorough and even application, crucial for optimal sun protection.
- Badger Stick: While quick, the stick format may not provide the same level of assurance that all areas are adequately covered.
Daily Use
- Sky&Sol: Ideal for daily use where a thorough and nourishing application is desired, prioritizing protection and skin health.
- Badger Stick: While convenient for touch-ups, it may not be the best choice for primary daily application where complete and even coverage is essential.
On-the-Go
- Badger Stick: Portable, but the application method may not be as effective as a cream for ensuring even protection.
- Sky&Sol: Less practical for travel, but the cream format allows for a more controlled and effective application, even when away from home.
Reapplication
- Badger Stick: Easier and cleaner for reapplication, but the texture may not be as pleasant or nourishing as a cream.
- Sky&Sol: While less convenient, the cream format allows for a more thorough reapplication, ensuring continued protection.
Ingredient Analysis
Sky&Sol SPF 50
Sky&Sol prioritizes a natural approach, focusing on ingredients that not only protect but also nourish the skin, with tallow as a star player.
Key Ingredients
- Non-Nano Zinc Oxide: Provides broad-spectrum SPF 50 protection, effectively shielding skin from harmful UVA and UVB rays.
- Organic Grass-Fed/Grass-Finished Tallow: A nutrient-rich fat that closely mirrors your skin's natural lipids, offering deep hydration and promoting optimal absorption.
- Organic Jojoba Oil: Helps to balance oil production and adds a layer of lightweight moisture, ensuring your skin stays comfortable throughout the day.
- Organic Beeswax: Creates a protective barrier, locking in moisture and shielding your skin from environmental stressors.
- Organic Vitamin E: A powerful antioxidant that protects skin from free radical damage, preventing premature aging.
- Radish Root Ferment Filtrate: Acts as a natural preservative, maintaining the integrity of the formula without harsh chemicals.
Ingredient Philosophy
- Focuses on using whole, recognizable ingredients that are both effective and skin-loving.
- Free from chemical UV filters, silicones, and artificial fragrances, prioritizing a clean and gentle formulation.
Read More: The Ultimate Guide to Best Sunscreen Ingredients for Daily Use
Read More: Discover the Best Natural Sunscreen Ingredients for Protection
Read More: The Benefits of Tallow Soap for Healthy and Glowing Skin
Badger Balm Sunscreen Face Stick SPF 35
Badger Balm emphasizes portability and simplicity, using a shorter ingredient list for a convenient on-the-go option.
Key Ingredients
- Zinc Oxide: Provides broad-spectrum SPF 35 protection.
- Organic Sunflower Oil: A lightweight oil that provides a base for the formula and offers some moisturizing benefits.
- Organic Beeswax: Helps to create a protective barrier on the skin.
- Sunflower Vitamin E: An antioxidant that helps protect the skin.
Read More: Beeswax for Skin: 5 Amazing Benefits & Uses
Read More: Beeswax vs Shea Butter: Which is Right for You?
Ingredient Comparison
While both sunscreens utilize natural ingredients, their formulations cater to different priorities. Let's compare their strengths.
Nourishment and Skin Health
- Sky&Sol goes beyond basic sun protection, providing deep nourishment and promoting overall skin health with ingredients like tallow and jojoba oil.
- Badger Balm prioritizes simplicity for portability, with a shorter ingredient list.
Ingredient Quality and Benefits
- Sky&Sol's tallow-rich formula offers unique moisturizing and skin-mimicking properties.
- Badger Balm's formula is simple, but may not offer the same level of skin-loving benefits as Sky&Sol.
For Sensitive Skin
- Both are generally gentle, but Sky&Sol's tallow formula is excellent at soothing and moisturizing dry sensitive skin.
- Badger Balm's simple formula may be suitable for those with very specific sensitivities, but it lacks some moisturizing benefits.
Protection and Performance
Beyond the application style, let's examine how these sunscreens perform in terms of protection and overall effectiveness. We'll look at SPF, hydration, and how they hold up under different conditions.
SPF and Protection
SPF Rating
- Sky&Sol: Offers a higher SPF 50 protection for more robust defense against UVB rays.
- Badger Balm: Provides SPF 35 protection.
Broad-Spectrum Protection
- Both provide broad-spectrum protection, guarding against both UVA and UVB rays.
Overall Protection
- Sky&Sol's higher SPF rating gives it an edge in terms of UVB protection, which is crucial for preventing sunburn.
Hydration and Comfort
Hydration Levels
- Sky&Sol: Tallow-rich formula provides superior and long-lasting hydration, making it ideal for dry skin.
- Badger Balm: While moisturizing, it may not offer the same level of intense hydration as Sky&Sol, especially for prolonged sun exposure.
Comfort During Wear
- Sky&Sol: Creamy texture provides a comfortable and nourishing feel, promoting healthy skin.
- Badger Balm: The stick format may not feel as comfortable or nourishing as a cream, especially for extended periods.
Addressing Specific Needs
Suitability for Different Skin Types:
- Sky&Sol: Tallow-rich formula is particularly beneficial for dry skin.
- Badger Balm: May be suitable for most skin types, but it is not as hydrating as Sky&Sol.
Performance During Activity
- Sky&Sol: Cream format may not be ideal for intense activity where sweat is a concern.
- Badger Balm: While convenient, the stick format may not provide the same level of even and thorough protection during vigorous activity.
Performance on Different Skin Tones
- Both may leave a white cast.
- Sky&Sol's cream format allows for more controlled application, which may help to minimize white cast.
Read More: 5 Best Sunscreens for Acne-Prone Skin (2025)
Read More: Best Sunscreens for Oily Skin (2025) - Non-Greasy
Read More: 5 Best Mineral Sunscreens for Face & Body In 2025
The Verdict
After a thorough comparison, it's time to determine which sunscreen truly stands out. Both Sky&Sol and Badger offer natural options, but their strengths and weaknesses cater to different needs and preferences.
Sky&Sol SPF 50
- Focus: Superior sun protection and deep nourishment through a tallow-rich cream formula.
- Application: Cream format allows for a thorough and controlled application, ensuring even coverage.
- Best For: Those prioritizing robust sun protection, intense hydration, and a nourishing experience. Particularly beneficial for dry skin.
Badger Balm Sunscreen Face Stick SPF 35
- Focus: Convenient and portable stick format for on-the-go use.
- Application: Stick format is convenient but may compromise even coverage and a luxurious feel.
- Best For: Those prioritizing portability and quick reapplication, but less concerned with thorough application and intense hydration.
Recommendations: Tailored to Your Needs
For Robust Sun Protection
- Sky&Sol's higher SPF 50 rating provides superior protection against UVB rays.
For Dry Skin and Nourishment
- Sky&Sol's tallow-rich formula offers intense and long-lasting hydration.
For Convenient Application
- Badger Balm's stick format is more convenient for on-the-go use.
For Thorough and Controlled Application
-
Sky&Sol's cream format allows for a more even and effective application.
Read More: Best Day & Night Moisturizer for Glowing Skin
Read More: What's Inside Sky&Sol Lip Jelly? (And Why It Matters)
Read More: The Benefits of Tallow Soap for Healthy and Glowing Skin