Natural mineral sunscreens are booming, and we're zeroing in on two popular SPF 30 options: Sky&Sol and Badger. Sky&Sol brings tallow-based nourishment, while Badger offers a minimalist 'clear zinc' formula.
Which is better? We're comparing textures, ingredients, and performance to help you choose your ideal natural SPF 30.
User Experience: Feel, Application, and Daily Wear
How a sunscreen feels on your skin can make or break your daily routine. Let's explore the textures, application processes, and overall comfort of Sky&Sol and Badger SPF 30.
Sky&Sol SPF 30
Sky&Sol SPF 30 Sunscreen is known for its rich, nourishing formula that caters to those who appreciate a more luxurious feel.
Texture and Application:
- The texture is thick and creamy, reflecting its tallow base.
- Application requires a bit more effort, needing thorough massaging to blend evenly.
- It leaves a noticeable dewy finish, giving the skin a hydrated, radiant look.
- While it may leave a white cast, it can be minimized with thin, even application.
Daily Wear:
- For dry skin, it provides excellent hydration throughout the day.
- Those with oily skin might find it too heavy for daily wear, especially in warm climates.
Badger Clear Zinc SPF 30
Badger Clear Zinc SPF 30 focuses on simplicity, offering a straightforward formula with their 'clear zinc' technology.
Texture and Application
- The texture is a cream, but lighter than Sky&Sol.
- It spreads more easily, making application quicker.
- The "clear zinc" formulation aims to reduce whitening, but thorough rubbing is still required.
- Q&A's indicate that powder makeup is recommended over liquid make up.
Daily Wear
- It feels lighter on the skin, making it comfortable for various skin types.
- The finish is less dewy than Sky&Sol, which can be preferable for oily skin.
- Q&A's indicate that some whitening can occur.
Daily Scenarios and Comfort
To see how these sunscreens perform in everyday situations, let's consider a few scenarios
Typical Daily Activities
- For indoor activities like office work, Badger's lighter feel might be more comfortable.
- For light outdoor activities, both offer adequate protection, but Sky&Sol provides extra nourishment.
Suitability for Skin Types
- Dry Skin: Sky&Sol provides superior moisture.
- Oily/Combination Skin: Badger's lighter texture is ideal.
- Sensitive Skin: Both are gentle, but Badger's minimal ingredient list is a plus for those with very sensitive skin.
Read More: 5 Best Sunscreens for Acne-Prone Skin (2025)
Read More: Best Sunscreens for Oily Skin (2025) - Non-Greasy
Read More: 5 Best Mineral Sunscreens for Face & Body In 2025
Ingredient Deep Dive
Beyond the feel, let's explore what's actually in these sunscreens. Both Sky&Sol and Badger prioritize natural ingredients, but their approaches differ. Let's break down the key ingredients and see how they contribute to daily skin health.
Sky&Sol SPF 30
Sky&Sol is all about harnessing the power of a few, carefully chosen natural ingredients, with tallow taking center stage.
Key Ingredients
- Zinc Oxide (Non-Nano): Provides broad-spectrum SPF 30 protection, shielding your skin from daily UV rays.
- Organic Grass-Fed/Grass-Finished Tallow: Rich in vitamins and fatty acids, mirroring your skin's natural oils for deep nourishment and absorption.
- Organic Jojoba Oil: Mimics your skin's sebum, offering lightweight hydration and balancing oil production.
- Organic Beeswax: Provides a protective barrier, locking in moisture.
- Organic Vitamin E: An antioxidant that protects skin from free radical damage.
- Radish Root Ferment Filtrate: Acts as a natural preservative.
Minimalist Approach
Sky&Sol avoids common irritants like fragrances, preservatives, and parabens, catering to sensitive skin.
Read More: The Ultimate Guide to Best Sunscreen Ingredients for Daily Use
Read More: Discover the Best Natural Sunscreen Ingredients for Protection
Badger Clear Zinc SPF 30
Badger takes minimalism to the next level with a formula containing only five ingredients, all focused on gentle protection.
Key Ingredients
- Zinc Oxide (18.75%): Provides broad-spectrum SPF 30 protection using "clear zinc" technology to minimize white cast.
- Organic Sunflower Oil: A lightweight oil that nourishes and moisturizes the skin.
- Organic Beeswax: Creates a protective barrier, helping to retain moisture.
- Sunflower Vitamin E: Provides antioxidant benefits.
- Organic Seabuckthorn Extract: Rich in antioxidants and vitamins, known for its skin-soothing properties.
Certified Organic & Non-GMO:
- Badger emphasizes the purity and quality of its ingredients with certifications.
C. Ingredient Comparison: Which Approach Wins?
Both brands champion natural ingredients, but their philosophies differ slightly. Which approach is better for your skin?
Simplicity vs. Variety:
- Badger's 5-ingredient formula is ideal for those seeking ultimate minimalism.
- Sky&Sol offers a slightly more diverse blend of natural ingredients.
Key Ingredient Focus:
- Sky&Sol highlights tallow for its unique skin-mimicking properties.
- Badger focuses on the combination of clear zinc with a few carefully selected organic ingredients.
For Sensitive Skin:
- Both are great choices, but Badger's 5 ingredient list is ideal.
For Dry Skin:
- Sky&Sol's tallow is more moisturizing
Read More: Is Beef Tallow Good for Skin? Benefits & Uses
Protection and Performance
SPF 30 is your daily shield against the sun, but how do Sky&Sol and Badger perform when it comes to long-term protection and overall skin health? Let's delve into their performance beyond the basic SPF rating.
SPF 30 Efficacy
Both sunscreens boast SPF 30, but what does that mean in practice for your daily routine?
Broad-Spectrum Protection:
- Both Sky&Sol and Badger provide broad-spectrum protection, guarding against both UVA (aging) and UVB (burning) rays.
- Badger has a critical wavelength ranging from 372nm to 375.89nm, offering excellent protection from UVA rays.
Mineral-Based Protection:
- Both utilize zinc oxide, a mineral filter that physically blocks UV rays, making them suitable for sensitive skin.
Daily Reliability:
When applied correctly and reapplied as needed, both offer reliable SPF 30 protection for daily use.
Hydration and Comfort
A sunscreen needs to be comfortable for all-day wear. How do these two feel on the skin throughout your daily activities?
Hydration Levels:
- Sky&Sol's tallow-based formula provides rich, lasting hydration, ideal for dry skin.
- Badger, while moisturizing, may not offer the same level of intense hydration as Sky&Sol.
Comfort During Extended Wear:
- Badger's lighter texture makes it comfortable for all-day wear, even in warmer conditions.
- Sky&Sol's thicker consistency might feel heavier for some, particularly during physical activity.
Addressing Specific Needs
Let's consider how these sunscreens cater to particular needs and concerns.
Sensitive Skin
- Both are good choices, but Badger's 5-ingredient formula is a standout for those with very sensitive skin or specific sensitivities.
- Sky&Sol is also gentle but contains more ingredients, increasing the chances of a reaction.
Performance Under Makeup
- Badger creates a smoother base for makeup due to its lighter texture.
- Sky&Sol may require powder to prevent makeup from sliding.
Light Exercise and Water Resistance
- Badger is water-resistant for 40 minutes, suitable for light activity.
- Sky&Sol may feel heavy during exercise.
Read More: Best Day & Night Moisturizer for Glowing Skin
Read More: What's Inside Sky&Sol Lip Jelly? (And Why It Matters)
Read More: The Benefits of Tallow Soap for Healthy and Glowing Skin
The Verdict
After a thorough examination, it's time to crown a champion in this natural SPF 30 showdown. Both Sky&Sol and Badger offer compelling benefits, but the 'better' choice ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences.
Sky&Sol SPF 30
- Focus: Deep nourishment and hydration through tallow.
- Texture: Rich and creamy, leaving a dewy finish.
- Ingredients: A blend of natural and organic ingredients, including tallow, jojoba oil, and beeswax.
- Best For: Dry skin, those seeking intense moisture, and those who appreciate a more luxurious feel.
- Considerations: May feel heavy for oily skin, potential for white cast if not applied carefully.
Badger Clear Zinc SPF 30
- Focus: Minimalist formula with "clear zinc" technology to reduce white cast.
- Texture: Lighter cream, easier to spread.
- Ingredients: Only 5 ingredients, all natural and mostly organic.
- Best For: Oily/combination skin, those seeking a simple and gentle formula, and those prioritizing minimal white cast.
- Considerations: May not provide as much intense hydration as Sky&Sol.